Suno is the Walking Dead

2 min read
by Joseph Perla

Suno is the walking dead.

Suno is the next Napster. The old Napster had 100 million users in 1999 and seemed unstoppable — until it lost everything. The major labels have already delivered the same checkmate to Suno. A music-AI company cannot survive if it trains on copyrighted catalogs without licensing and pays rights-holders nothing — neither for training nor for output. Suno pays effectively zero per generated song, and that alone makes its economics and valuation unworkable the moment any real licensing or settlement cost enters the picture.

Tech journalists breathlessly covered the Udio deal as if it were a sign that Suno might license its way out. It isn't. Udio got completely reset — lost its technical cofounder, laid off its team, and now has to build an entirely new product from scratch, which will take six to twelve months. That is what capitulation looks like.

The labels have made it clear they will not let an unlicensed system replace their businesses. Any model that builds value on top of recorded music has to license it. Udio has already shown it can be done, and the next generation of rights-compliant models — like Turntable.ai — are arriving this year with licensing and monetization built in from day one. Those are viable paths. Suno's path is not. VCs have been betting that this administration would provide cover for AI training copyright violations, but this month's news suggests that the administration's political cover may itself be running out.

Every Suno output carries an invisible tracking watermark in the waveform. Once Suno is bankrupted and its assets handed to the labels, every single output ever generated will be traceable and tainted, all of its outputs and revenues owed to the labels. Using Suno today, instead of a licensed model, means risking everything you build with it — every track, every project, every dollar of revenue — on a company that has already lost its legal fight.

This leaves Suno in the same position Napster and Grooveshark were in: huge usage, lots of investor money, and no legal or economic foundation under any of it. The hundreds of millions just invested will flow into penalty payments and legal costs. The industry has made its move. The game is over.

Enjoyed this essay?

Follow me for more insights on technology, startups, and the future.